I'm a member of four international antique car clubs, I contribute to all of their forums because I have a car/truck (s) that are of their marque, therefore I have some knowledge, mechanical, etc., about their vehicles.
Most of the antique car clubs are structured in the same manner, they reputedly only cater to "the correct restoration, preservation of their particular brand of car. Certain members get all bent out of shape if any mention is made on a forum pertaining to the alteration of any portion of a given vehicle. The same attitude appears on the Barn from time to time.
One club that I belong to has a great award wining publication that comes out every other month. It also "had" a great international forum, covering just about any country you could name, North/South America, Europe, Middle East, Australia an New Zealand.
The traffic on the forum got so heavy, the speed was at a snail's pace. The Board of directors did not want to spend the money to get a faster, better server. People complained, nothing happened..
Then the Board announced that to save money they were going to phase out the club publication in favor of an on-line bulletin, and an on-line club, with membership dues, with the thought that they could embrace people that lived in small communities where local/regional groups did not exist.. That went over like a lead balloon.. A splinter group started another forum, where-in modifications/modified vehicles could be discussed..
As the traffic on the official club forum dwindled, the Board of Directors tried to modify the club requirements to include modified cars. The majority of the Board was "old school purists", however, they did bend enough to allow any vehicle that was thirty years old.. Hello, that opened the membership up to muscle cars of the '60's/70's.
Two years ago a new president and some new Board members opened a FaceBook account in lieu of buying a new server for the club forum.
Yes, the Facebook site is very active, more so than the club forum, however, the content is mostly of the social nature, like gossip over a neighbors fence.
The net result of this whole thing is that the official club forum will go for weeks with no contributions, the spinoff forum is very user friendly with multiple contributions every day.
The net result of changing things, i.e., fixing something that ain't broken, is that one has to be very careful as to how you go about it..