Zippi, I believe that you are using the wrong door check strip. m Your door check should look like the ones in the enclosed photo.
Thanks for all the info guys. I do have those metal & rubber door check straps in place as well but they are very loose with the wrong bolts. I just took my 37 in last night to have all the interior re-done. I'll pop the door panel off and take a better look once it comes back. It's about 40 min away from the house. It'll be a long 5 weeks.