1928 closed cab back panel- repair or replace?

[Jack 34pu]

I'm working on a 28/29 cab and the two back panels are dented, warped, and rusted thru where they attach. I've seen some very nice pu's with awful looking, wavy back panels. I'm sure I would have as much or more $$ in repairing them as picking up a new set at Bratton's or other supplier. I want a nice look and $500 doesn't go far in the autobody shop these days. Those of you that have been there before, what do you say? This will not be a points pickup.

 

[Dave in MN]

I replaced the lower panel years ago when I restored my '28 CCPU. I worked with a dented and rusted upper panel...I wish I had replaced the upper also as I see the waves in it when the light hits it just so. You asked for opinions and I think you will get varied replies. Enjoy the restoration...

 

[painterrick]

Id go with replacing it .So hard to straighten these panels and you are right 500 dollars doesn't go far in the body shop

 

[Russ B]

I did new sheet metal on my closed cab about 20 years ago. They still needed significant work, about a quarter inch off in width or height, I do not remember. They have some waviness still. In retrospect, I would have fixed the originals, if doing it again.