I ran a Winfield R1 in a 59A 60 years ago.
The idle was smooth as the stock cam.
A real Winfield, not a copy. A stock 8CM or EAB cam would probably perform better.
Winfield had the cams to have for flathead 4 bangers in the 20's and 30's and he did most of the winners for the Offy's but he was always way behind with the flathead Ford V8's.
The Isky 404, one of the most successful flathead circle track cams ever made was an almost direct copy of the Winfield #4 Offy grind.
Pete
Not to stray too far off topic, but does the #4 grind need radius lifters like the 404?
Yes.