Window Channel kits

[Stanley]

I have a 35 3-window body that I am restoring. Looking thru the various parts vendors for window channel kits for the doors, I see they have two different types. one is with felt for the door & garnish, and the other is with rubber bumpers on the door and garnish.
My question is which one works better, or does it matter?
Havn't bought any yet but would appreciate info from people who have installed these.
Stan.

 

[Pete from OZ]

Hi Stan,
My January built 3 window has the rubber bumpers on the Door and Garnish Moulds. It sure would let lot,s of water in, and I would also likes to fit the Felts, as to give better protection.

Pete from OZ.