Hi Steve,
I got down to my parts car and picked up the other floor pan. It is really in good shape. It is aluminum, it is not cut anywhere, but has a little distortion around one of the pedal holes, other than that it is very nice. Remember, these don't show after they are installed. The bottom gets some form of rustproofing, the top gets screwed down, covered with jute (or sound proofing of some kind), then gets a rubber floor mat, and sometimes even some carpeting. Even the little distortion around the pedal hole will be covered with the pedal seals so there really are no major issues. You can buy a reproduction in steel for $165 from outfits like Mac's but they will definitely not outlast an aluminum floor. Think about it. Best wishes, Toby