Marcos roadster is about as close as anyone will get
he collected NOS parts for years, the restoration he did on it is phenomenal
Yes, all the way thru reading this I was thinking "How soon we forget." regarding Marco's Roadster restoration.
Now the NOS debate becomes a controversial topic sometimes for many reasons both Pro & Con. Up until about a year ago I had collected about 75% of an entire running gear for a late '31 in NOS for a fine-point build. Since that time I have begun to sell off some of those items simply because for me, I realized that as soon as I installed them, they were no longer NOS parts but were instead 'used parts'.
Of the two sides of the debate, personally in these modern times I am not impressed with someone building a fine-point car out of NOS parts for two simple reasons;
A) Marco has already done it (which means we are only copying what he set the bar so high on!)
B) ...anyone can bolt on NOS parts!
Allow me to elaborate why I said this. Today, finding NOS parts is
WAY easier than when Marco did it 20-25 years ago simply because it is easier to find parts via the internet and networking today. In addition to that, identifying the parts today is much easier with the information that is available via Bensen, Judging Stds, and various websites who are posting information than what he had available to him then.
2nd, (...know what Marco went thru restoring NOS parts and you will realize I am not taking anything away from Marco or his car by saying this) The degree of difficulty comes when someone returns a component to a former state in thorough, exacting details. That is called 'restoration'. Most folks will never have a clue how much work Will Cronkrite actually performed restoring his Panel Truck. Will spent countless hours at the archives researching each and every part on that vehicle. For example, in an effort to save money Will would make a drawing of a part either by free-hand or in Solidworks, and then take that to the Bensen Library and transcribe the measurements and details off of the print onto his drawing. On the missing or more complicated components, Will would search for, and research the proper print to purchase. The reason he did this is so he could "restore" or fabricate that component with exacting standards. When comparing this procedure to buying a NOS component, which do you feel has more degree of difficulty?
Another example; a couple of years ago we were restoring a 1928 Sport Coupe. Luckily for us Bill Sturm still had a bolt of the original fabric to upholster this Coupe in. Therefore all we had to do is write a check to pay for the material and we were on our way. On Will's truck, the fabric was unavailable in any original or an accurate reproduction. In that scenario Will and his wife Peggy set out to accurately duplicate the original material he needed. After many hours of devotion they accomplished it. So between the two scenarios, which do you feel has more difficulty and level of craftsmanship involved --writing a check or hand making it??
I could go on with other examples but I think you begin to see why I feel 'assembling' a Model-A today out of NOS parts vs. actually accurately 'restoring' a Model-A is much more impressive.
