Years ago, when we used "reclaimed" oil, the reclaimed oil was left to sit for a few weeks or more. That way the contaminents in the oil would settle out and the oil would be clean. Once they started putting detergents in the oil the contaminents refused to settle out and that process went out the window.
I think a full flow oil filter is a good idea, maybe an expense to consider the next time you have the intake manifold off.
It sounds like the oil you are using in your A has the zinc anti-wear additive which is the correct type to use. Either you bought it that way or added it yourself. Everyday modern oils both regular petroleum and synthetic do not contain zinc compound additives as they affect the catalyst in the catalytic converters. I am not familiar with the pollution controls in your Geo but if it has a standard catalytic converter I would not use your 500mile oil in it.