Tom and Codder, I'll send you the pics (Large) of the two fenders. These have never been on a car, had pool marks from the original paint dip and were cleaned, primed and painted on both sides. .
Your car looks fine to me just as it is. I think you should enjoy your car and not focus on this fender issue. No one will notice this minor fender difference so you should put it out of your mind and concentrate on more important things on your A that may need attention.
Since I live on the Cape as well, I could meet up with you and your car someday.
You will know it is me because I will be the only person still aware of your fender "problem" to be able to stand next to your vehicle and point to that rear fender with the truncated bead.