I was looking to paint my wheels the light yellow look that they call Tacoma Wheat in later years and earlier called Straw (I think), but it is a light yellow and not the off white that your picture shows.
I did a bunch of looking and trying and then found a perfect match for what looked to be Tacoma Wheat and Straw in some pictures. Again this has that light yellow look
I found it in Home Depot, as others didn't carry it.
It's Rustoleum Painters touch 2X Warm Yellow gloss and I like the way mine came out. Since it doesn't cost much, if you think this is the color you are looking for, you might buy a can and give it a try. The gloss makes it look really nice and likely more durable that flat.