I just looked at catalogs from 3 different repo parts vendors and they all show the same oversized (thick) radiator support rubber pad. I'm pretty sure each of these outfits gets their rubber parts from Dennis Carpenter.
I fear that by using this thick pad, the studs at the bottom of the radiator support might not be long enough to permit installation of the springs and nuts below the frame crossmember center bracket.
I lost my old Metro Moulded parts catalog, but I would bet that they offer the correct pad thickness. The factory pad couldn't have been more than 1/4" thick. I've seen enough of the original pads to know. Both of my '55 cars have replacement pads on them and they are a little bit thicker than the factory pad, but do allow for the springs to go on with a little bit of play between the coils. However, those were installed decades ago, so apparently, the repro parts mfrs are using a different mold.
My suggestion: Call Metro Moulded Parts and ask them to measure the thickness of the pad they offer. If they tell you it is 3/8" thick or less, BUY IT.
Alternative: Obtain a flat 1/8" thick rubber pad and cut 2 pieces to size and punch holes in them for wiring them to the bottom of the radiator support bracket.
Note: The factory original "baling wire" that was used to attach the rubber pad to the bottom of the radiator support was actually a 12 gage piece of COPPER wire (single strand, as in bare household electrical ground conductor). You got a piece of that laying around, just cut a piece long enough.
Here is how the factory attached the rubber pad to the radiator support:
Bend the wire to a U-shape to align with the two little holes at the bottom of the radiator support. From the top, poke the ends of of the wire thru the holes in the radiator support, then poke the rubber pad thru the wires sticking down from below. Pull the copper wire tight so that it is flat at the top, then bend over the two wires to meet in the middle of the rubber pad at the bottom. Twist the wires together one time and bend over flat against the pad. The wire needs to be real tight so that the bent over wire at the bottom of the pad sinks into the rubber pad. That way, the rubber pad will sit on the front crossmember without the wire rubbing against it (theoretically). It appears to me that the factory installations may NOT have INITIALLY been good enough to have the wires completely sunken into the rubber, BUT, after a year or so of heat from the radiator transmitting to the rubber, the wires would eventually sink into the rubber and seal the rubber pad good to the top of the crossmember. And it wouldn't hurt anything, since the two little springs would simply be allowed to expand a little bit after the pad had settled.
Over and out.