problem with rear fenders

[Dune Country]

These are off of the CCPU,sandblasted, is one damaged or off of something else?
what is the original profile?

 

[Farrell In Vancouver]

The one on the left may be a "Beavertail" thats had some damage and been hammered a bit. the one on the right looks standard. I have one of each on my coupe but I can hide mine with bumperettes. Not so much so on a CCPU

 

[mot]

post a photo of the front of the fender where it fits the splash shield
and also what year vehicle do you have

 

[Dune Country]

here is a picture of the fronts, it is a '31 CCPU

 

[Aerocraft]

I believe that both of the fenders have been worked on which is why they don't match. It appears to me that the one on the left has a twist in it. I suggest that you find another car that has what appears to you to be an "original" shape, make a pattern and shape your fenders to match. The early '28 "beavertail" fenders have a much different shape than either of your fenders. Gar Williams