Thanks guys.....I guess they must have sold a ton of these to the engine re-builders. On another forum, I had asked If I could use these on a newly reground cam, and the answer was 'No'. I am still debating this response within myself, as they are in such 'new' shape. I also checked them with a micrometer straightedge, and they do have a very slight convex radius. I wonder if new lifters today have this radius? If not, all the more wants me to use them....just a thought. Robert
Just my opinion based on 30+ years building engines as a hobby, and getting paid for it.
Don't re-use them without re-finishing the bases (or using new ones). Flathead cams are not cheap.
Used/bad/marginal lifters plus new cam usually equals bad cam in short order.
This is from way back - Always replace a cam and lifters as a set. If you take the engine apart make sure the same lifter goes back on the lobe it came from (same with pushrods, rockers, etc.)
The most critical part of the cam/lifter life together is that first 20-minute break in. The lifter bases and cam lobes will mate to each other during that time. This generates lots of heat. That's why you need to use lots of break-in lube and keep the rpm up in the 1800-2800 range and constantly vary the engine speed. If you need to adjust something, shut the motor down. Don't idle it, etc. Run a break-in oil in addition to break in lube on teh cam...
Keeping the revs up actually results in better lubrication due to the splash oiling going on.
IMO the best cams come from the factory with a black nitrided finish on the lobes. It looks rough, and you will wonder how the heck is this going to work? Trust the cam grinder, he knew what he was doing. That nitriding is even harder than the shiny "flame hardened" and shiny ground lobes, and it holds the lube better during break in.
After that 20-minute break in. Do what you want.
My 2 cents