Looks like I wasn't clear in this question. I am not asking where everybody sets their GAV. This is not a question about how your car runs with different GAV settings.
I am asking about the procedure for setting the air mixture at the carb, which is done with one of the two screws on the carb body.
Ignored in most procedures is any reference to where - when setting this air mixture - the GAV should be set.
On the website model-a.org they do get specific and state that the GAV should be fully open during this procedure. But that is the only place I find such guidance, and there is no explanation as to why it should be so.
Why would you set the idle mixture screw ( slotted screw on the front side of the carb) while the GAV is set at a position it will (probably) never be in when you're actually
driving the car ? (IE: " all the way open " )
I've been wrenching on cars and farm machinery for nearly 40 years, and the proceedure has been the same for adjusting just about every carb: start the engine and run until warm, the proceed with adjustments.
On those models with an adjustable main jet ( GAV ), you adjust that first, to where the engine runs best, then idle down and adjust the idle mixture screw.
You may have to alternate between the idle mixture screw and the idle stop screw (which controls the opening of the throttle butterfly ) to get the ideal ideal mixture adjustment.
For my '28 (Zenith carb) , with the engine fully warmed-up, these settings are:
(First make sure points are clean and correctly gapped, and the engine is properly timed).
GAV 1/4 to 1/2 turn open from lightly-seated
Idle mixture screw - about 1-1/4 to 1-1/2 turns open from lightly seated.
Throttle and spark levers all the way up against their upper stops.
That said, apparently every A is slightly different... what I have listed for my car is a reasonable starting-point; tweak your car to where it runs best, and make a note of those settings.
I see no reason to adjust the idle mixture with the GAV fully open.