Hi Bob,
Problem No. 1:
A. Above Replies No. 1 & 2 are Right On; i.e., dirty 80+ year old hard iron rust and/or sand in tank exiting and marring a soft non-ferrous metal valve ..... best easy & quick solution to stop cause of problem: Install Gas Valve Shut-Off Screen, Part No. A-9194 at Bert's Model A.
B. Lapping may or may not work for extremely minor gas valve damage on damaged shut-off valves; however, for damage resulting in deeper soft metal cuts, a new valve will be needed. (One Model A parts technician reported years ago his lapping of 100 shut-off valves picked up at swap meets ...... 2 out of 100 were successful .... he humbly admitted he wasted 5 working days and gave up.)
Problem No 2:
A. Carburetor or gas line or gas line fittings leaking gas.
B. Could be leaks at carburetor float valve, carburetor gaskets, carburetor drain plug, etc., etc., all of which requires further investigation.
C. Many concentrate more on Problem No. 1, e.g., first fix shut-off valve; next, when stopping engine, close shut-off valve and allow Model A carburetor to run out of gas to avoid carburetor leaks.