I'm starting to think that 40 degrees of advance is not unrealistic
under certain conditions for our As. Here's an article that helps explain this...
http://www.hotrod.com/articles/set-ignition-curves-create-optimal-performance/
I know it is focuses on a more modern engine, but the principals are similar on any internal combustion engine.
You need more spark lead as RPM increases (to a point) in order to light the charge in time to create maximum cylinder pressure at the ideal point after TDC. For the engine in the article, this is about 35 degrees before TDC at 2600 RPM and above
when the engine is pulling and there is little or no vacuum. At light throttle conditions over 2600 RPM (like steady state cruising) even more advance is required since the throttle is barely cracked. the A/F mixture is lean and not tightly packed and will burn slower because of this. In order to hit maximum cylinder pressure at that ideal point after TDC, the charge has to be lit even earlier. In the example in the article, about 45 degrees of total (initial + centrifugal + vacuum) advance is required. Since there is plenty of vacuum at these conditions, the vacuum advance adds the required additional advance.
All forms of advance in a modern engine (initial, centrifugal, vacuum) are handled by the driver with the spark advance lever on stock Model As. Advance is retarded to TDC to start the engine, and advance is added as RPM and load conditions require. Theoretically, we should be constantly "fooling" with the advance lever in order to maximize performance and fuel economy. This would be a pain in the butt and probably result in only minor gains, so we move the lever to the position that we have found is the best compromise and go for a drive.
So, my current (unproven) theory, is that there is a use for the 40 degrees of advance that is obtainable (also unproven) when the spark lever is pulled all the way down. This would be during light throttle, steady state cruising at high (for our cars) RPM. Let's say 40-50 MPH on level ground.
I tried this with my 30 Tudor. I run with the spark lever about 2/3 advanced. At 40 MPH when I pull the lever all the way down I do note a slight increase in RPM and smoothing
(slight). Maybe not enough to worry about. The downside of doing this is that if I forget I've done it and then don't retard the spark when the engine is pulling again and I'm into the throttle, preignition (detonation) could occur which is bad for any engine...especially one with a babbitt lower end.
If our engines are capable of 40 degrees of advance, I believe Henry knew it and made it possible for a reason. My next step would be to measure how many degrees of advance are
actually occurring at the crank during full movement of the advance lever. Any good ideas on how to do this?