Hi Jay,
As you already mentioned and questioned when you pull out your choke:
"It is like I am pumping gas into the carburetor. Can anyone explain why this is?"
YES ..... A Simple Physical Experiment !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1. Get two (2) drinking straws & label one F for Fuel and one A for Air.
2. Place one end of the F straw in a 10 quart bucket full of water and allow one end of the other A straw to remain in open air.
3. Place your mouth on the opposite ends of the F straw and the A straw.
4. Like your Model A engine's strong intake valve suction force, form a suction with your mouth & draw in both F straw water from the bucket and A straw air from open air.
5. To simulate a "possible" reduced flow of fuel from inside the bottom drain in your possibly dirty Model A fuel tank, (rust, dirt and/or mice crap), squeeze your F straw to reduce your water flow 75%; e.g., now ...... too much air & not enough fuel to run an engine.
6. To compensate for reduced F straw water flow, (like with your choking intake air with your choke), you squeeze your A straw an amount to reduce air flow; e.g., now you have similar proportional amount of water flow and air flow as that of 4. above ........ and ...... because you are like your engine with the same "strong" suction force; the water velocity increases and the air velocity increases such that you are getting both enough balanced air & gas to operate your engine.
7. Getting back to screens, mosquitoes and fly swatters, an in tank screen is a tall cylindrical screen as opposed the flat screen near your carburetor.
8. The mice crap & rust that settled to the tank's bottom which clogs a tank drain can usually clog the bottom of the tall tank screen cylinder ...... but not the top of the screen; hence, fuel is allowed to "freely" flow through the unclogged "top" of the cylindrical tank screen down through the interior of the screen to the gas line.
9. Not to be facetious; but, if you experiment with straws F & A, please do not place mice crap in the bucket to prove this fact; however, "if" a dirty tank is your problem, you will see that in tank "screens" actually work just like keeping out mosquitoes out of a house & mice crap out of a carburetor.
In accordance with reply #4 & #7 ........ just hope this helps not to forget Model A Carburetor Choking Physics 101 and those who continue to ignore in Model A tank screens, & "possible" often occurring gas tank clogging mice crap, rust & such that stop engines ... but re-start after choking.