"I would think that the car would start even with bad gaskets. Am i wrong?"
Manifold gaskets: I recently installed a manifold set on a Model A engine that was in a box with other parts accompanying an unfinished amateur restoration. I used new copper gaskets with gland rings. The engine refused to start. After laboriously checking the usual suspects with no success, I used a 0.010" feeler gauge between each manifold runner and the gaskets. I couldn't get it between the exhaust manifold, but it slipped up easily between the intake and the engine block. I incrementally tried thicker feeler gauges until the 0.025" wouldn't squeeze in. Apparently, someone had put two manifolds together, whose intake had been on a set that had been trued so that the intake manifold runners were about 0.025" short of sealing against the engine block. I swapped that manifold set with a known good one and viola! The engine started right up. So, in this case the gap was too wide to allow gas to be sucked up into the cylinders. The intake manifold must have a good seal in order to start the engine and have it run properly.
Head gasket: On a cross country drive with a Riley two-port OHV conversion, the engine kept blowing out head gaskets. Before I reached my destination 1500 away, I had changed head gaskets twice alongside the road in the desert between Arizona and Kansas. NOT an easy job with a heavy OHV conversion, believe me! Anyway, the third head gasket began to blow out one cylinder at a time until I had only two functioning cylinders left when I needed to stop for gas. Surprisingly, the engine started on the back two cylinders and ran that way (albeit slowly) for the next 20 miles before the third cylinder blew out. Limping along on one cylinder like an old-time hit-and miss engine, I made it to the next town just as the final cylinder blew out. The engine would not start then. So, in this case, a bad head gasket would not allow the engine to start, but it did on two cylinders. 'Dunno if it would have started on one cylinder. I doubt it.
Marshall