In the last 55 years I have owned multiple cars of each of the four years of production. I also have spent considerable time reading the history of the Ford Motor Company and it's many manufacturing contributors - Like Sorensen, etc.
In reviewing both of these two facets, I have come to three conclusions:
1. The 1928 & 1929 years produced cars of exceptional quality in both material and 'fit & finish'. The 1928 had a number of 'start up' bugs to be worked out. Just like today, I would not want the first year of production, unless very late in the production year. The 1929 had all the exceptional quality of material and 'fit & finish', without the 'bugs' of the 1928 models.
2. After the crash of Black Friday of October 1929, a whole new element entered into all manufactures of all products across America, including the Ford Motor Company. So the new models of 1930, while indeed intering the more modern design norm of the thirties, had to suffer the effects of the Great Depression - a cheapening of materials, and a short-cutting of 'fit & finish'. This reality continued through the 1931 model year.
3. For the 1931 cars, while 'cheaper built' than the '28 * '29 cars, did benefit greatly from four years of Dealer and Service Field feed back, which resulted in a car with engineering improvements as well as improved drive ability, service/maintenance ability and reliability.
- So it is that I have both a late (December) '28 and a late (Jan.'32) '31 Ford Model A. I also like the sporty adventure of an open car, so my '28 is a Phaeton. And I like the sensible practicality of a closed car, so my '31 is a Dlx Coupe. I like the styling of both 1928/'29 and the 1930/'31, so my two cars represent each of those two styles. The '28 I have kept bone stock, factory spec.; while the '31 I have 'supped up' for 60 mph long distance touring.
- Doug Vieyra - Eureka, Calif