dshebuski, I hadn't heard that they shorten the battery life. Some say that they don't need them or they could present a fire hazard. I've been using them on my bikes, lawn tractors, boat, travel trailer and the A batteries that don't get used in the winter, for a LONG time and I haven't had any problems. I use timers that kick on for 1 hour a day just to keep 'em topped up so they are ready to go when I am. Just what I do, not sayin' its right, just works for me.