My $.02 worth. FIRST, I take a piece of 3/8 X 3" Aluminum flat bar that I got from one of my Machinist and I wrap some machinist cloth around it and sand the face of the head where the water pump mounts to see just how "flat" the surface is. IF need be I dress that with a flat machinist file, then some 400, 600 then either 800 or 1000 grit sand paper. Its best to start and know that you have a good "Flat" surface and are getting "FULL" face contact with your gasket. Once that is accomplished THEN a little bit of Permatex skim on the face of the water pump and head and you can bet, the lower end of the torque spectrum will be ALL that is needed for a good, tight, proper seal and not over stress any of the components.
ALSO the above torque "range" quoted will depend on IF the bolt is torqued "dry" or with some form of thread lube. SO keep that in mind as well AS a lubed fastener will require less torque than dry!!!
ALSO as another aside, I "just" did a rebuild on a 1935 with stock Aluminum heads following the Flattening of the head surface and I torqued those bolts (A307's/NOT Grd 5's with the mill marks sanded off and painted) to 12 Fts pounds. NO leaks at all. I have run it through three heat cycles up to 180 coolant temp and not one leak or drip!!!!