A friend of mine in CA made me a small batch of 20 in the correct thickness (around 75% the thickness of those everyone sells) and they were made from Viton which is the most durable , They were very good, but it took us a long time just to sell those twenty. Unfortunately my friend Randy has passed away and the tooling seemed to have been scraped, so making another run is not possible.
So, we are back to selling the typical seal and it will work but is too thick as David mentions primarily it seems when using a original firewall. (at least from what I hear from customers).