We ordered our 1st PT Cruiser 13 years ago in 2000 for my wife, before any were available to the public. We still have it, only maintenance we have ever done are air and oil changes and a $60.00 rear hub, (has not had a tune-up yet and passes the smog test every time), everything else other than the tires and battery are still factory original with no problems.
My middle daughter drives a 2010 PT.
I drive a 2009 PT I bought new for $11,800 including a Limited Lifetime Drivetrain Warranty as my construction vehicle (an 8' ladder fits inside with the hatch closed).
All (3) have been 100% dependable and trouble free.
PT loser ? NOT in my opinion....and like it or not, they bear a strong resemblance to my 37 Tudor Slantback, which is why I bought these in the first place. (They even have a hood prop in the same place as my 37 and if you try to close the hood with the prop in place, you will kink the hood just like our old Fords).