I just got a rebuilt engine, and chose the 6.5:1 head. Observations from the first few hundred miles:
1. Louder. This was the first and most immediate impression. The standard exhaust system was not designed for the greater gas energy. The Wretched Roadster has no sound insulation, no windows, and a cloth top. I would expect an insulated closed car would be quieter.
2. More power. For example, pulls up hills in 3rd gear that required 2nd gear with the standard head. This roadster was pretty peppy with the old engine but it’s noticeably stronger now. This would be of greater benefit with a heavier body style.
3. The higher power suggests that a higher (lower numerically) rear end ratio, or an overdrive would make it more pleasant. The engine revs more quickly to your intended speed and feels eager to go faster but the engine does not sound happy at these revs. I presume it would still have enough horsepower if turning a bit slower, and would sound and feel less frantic.
4. More sensitive to small throttle adjustments. It reminds me of a terrier eager for another inch of leash. I readjusted my foot position and the car jumped suddenly. With the original head it just didn’t have the ready torque to change velocity so quickly.
5. Much stronger compression braking. I used to remove my foot from the accelerator in third gear when I saw a traffic light a block away, and be at easy speed for braking when I neared the intersection. Now I must slowly reduce the accelerator or the car slows very abruptly.
6. Speed of rotation of the starter. It is still using the 6 volt system and the starter spins the engine more slowly. Of course, the compression is higher so more resistant. I’ve seen no need for 12-volt conversion so far. We’ll see if the 6 volt system can cope.
7. Forget hand cranking to start. See number 6. No big deal, a rolling start will suffice if needed.
8. It is not as sweet, not as smooth, not as leisurely. The original power restricted me to drive more gently. Again, the puppy pulling on the leash. Philosophically it is less satisfying because I value experiencing the same sensations as people who drove the car for nine decades before me. This applies to me, maybe not you. It’s not measurable on a dynamometer or stopwatch.
I am a relative newcomer to the Model A hobby and I only represent these thoughts based on my personal experience, not suggesting they are rules.