Having been a judge more times than I have had one of my cars judged, I never argue or complain about any deduction. I know all are volunteers and of the times I have judged, only 1 owner was ever really obnoxious about something. He seemed to think that because he spent a lot of money on his car (a 32) it was correct. You could see in the gap at the bottom of the spare tire cover that the tire itself was WELL used had very little tread I. pointed this out to the Deputy Judge, and he made a very small deduction. When the irate owner was yelling at the Deputy Judge, The Deputy calmly asked the owner "Do you think this car came off the assembly line with a nearly worn-out spare?" I had to move to the next car so the owner couldn't see my smile. Last judging sheet I saw said that all 5 tires needed to match.
Your example of the '32 owner with the worn tire hit too close to home I'm afraid.
I must ask, "how does an owner feel worthy of an award when he knows full well that he'd circumvented (cheated) the system"?
I've been the deputy in the '39 / '40 class a number of times. Like you, I have experienced the guys that think because they spent a ton of money, they should score highly.
On the opposite side of the proverbial coin, there have been those that have truly wanted to learn and do better the next time the car was to be shown. Those guys make my task very enjoyable. They tend to be more of the "hands on" owners.
The last Auburn meet was my worst experience to date. Two guys were total ahol--. Sorry, but they were...
One car, a wagon, was perhaps (on a good day) a 750 point car. The owner thought the car was "perfect" and stormed out after the judging. The other, the owner of a business coupe, a VERY nice business coupe, was VERY upset as my team caught a number of things that were not caught on his prior concourse.
All of my attempts to explain to him that "it's nice to have different folks addressing the car to help you achieve the best restoration" fell on deaf ears.
He figured if the first group missed something, it should be overlooked going forward. Yes, he said that.
I believe (sadly) that the attitude of "everyone wins" regardless of worthiness has permeated the concourse.
I miss the days when most guys earned (wanted to earn) their award.
By the way, I always take my time explaining, in detail, any and all deductions to the owner. I figure we are all there to learn and to strive for "better". I take it upon myself to make that task easier moving forward.