Coils an condensers and other components of teh distributor should not know the difference between number 2 and number 134. Have you checked for something like a foouled out number two spark plug.
The distributor housing sometimes has internal shorts or open circuits. I know you tried a different housing. But just to make sure, measure the resistance between the #2 point inside the distributor housing and the connection on the outside for the strap for #2 plug. It should measure close to zero ohms, less than one ohm. You may need to file or scratch the point inside the housing to get a good contact.